Dog Behavior Recordsigns of fearfulness and/or aggressionby Pam Green, © 2004, 2005 |
I have modified this table from an evaluation form published in Dr Karen Overall DVM's text "Clinical Behavioral Medicine for Small Animals" and used at the University of Pennsylvania Vet School to enable clients to evaluate dogs for signs of aggression. I modified the table to include signs of fearfulness and signs of calm or happy acceptance. This chart can be used by Rescuers to insist that owners surrendering dogs give a detailed an honnest report of potential behavior problems. It could also be used in the foster home to evaluate the dog and to measure progress. It could be used by an owner who is preparing to seek help from a dog behaviorist , or used to monitor progress of treatment.
I prepared this form for Rescue use in Bouvier Club of Northern California, hence the specific local references to the Marin Humane Society and to the U.C. Davis Vet Med Teaching Hospital. In other locations, substitute any equally qualified professional level resource. Any dog showing the more serious signs of aggression MUST be seen by a board certified Veterinary Behaviorist or by a certified Applied Animal Behaviorist who is well experienced in dealing with canine aggression problems. Some sites giving listings of such qualified specialists are given on my Farewell page.
The evaluation form itself can take a while to load, but it should be ready by the time you have read the introductory material.
I appologize that you may have to scroll horizontally to read this chart. I know everyone hates to have to scroll horizontally, but sometimes there is no choice in order to get in all the needed columns. If your browser allows you to reduce or enlarge overall size, reducing size below 100% may eliminate the need to scroll horizonally. Likewise changing your font size to a smaller one, if that remains readable. In printing , set up your page to print landscape mode, ie width greater than height. Sorry about this. In Word, I had the reaction column headings set up to go vertically, but HTML does not allow that. Maybe I will get around to making a PDF version you can download.
Notice that the reaction headings are color coded. The accepting reactions are coded light green (pale grey on greyscale monitor). The fearful reactions are coded light yellow (white on a greayscale monitor). Be aware that fear can easily lead active self-defensive aggression and thus to a bite if the freezing or fleeing reaction does not cause the threat percieved by the dog to go away. The "freeze / stiffen" reaction is coded light orange because it could be fearful or aggressive ; many people fail to notice this reaction, but it is well worth noticing ! The aggressive reactions are coded in a lighter pink for the serious warning reactions and darker pink for the most seriously aggressive reactions. Of course a "snap" can range from one that misses by many inches, in which case it is a very serious warning that was absolutely intended to miss, to one that misses by fractions of an inch, in which case either it was intended to miss or the target moved very swiftly to avoid a bite. A "bite" can range from a very light contact that was not intended to hurt , but merely to protest, to a totally serious bite that sends the recipient to the Emergency Room for extensive repairs. If you are sufficiently alert to signs in the yellow, orange, and light pink sections, you can avoid triggering the dangerous dark pink ones; reactions in any of these sections mean that the dog will need to be carefully desensitized and counter-conditioned in regard to that particular situation or stimulus and to similar ones until his reactions are consistantly in the green "accepting" section, or else the dog's life must be managed to prevent that particular situation and similar ones from ever occurring.
SITE INDEX | BOUVIER | RESCUE | DOG CARE |
PUPPY REARING | TRAINING | PROBLEMS | WORKING DOGS |
BOOKS | VERSE | IMAGES | MISCELLANEOUS |
Purpose :
The purpose of this record is to help detect, evaluate, and design treatment for any behavior problems your dog may have. If you are unwilling to fill out this form in complete truthfulness, Rescue will be unable to accept this dog. This information may be shared with the dog's eventual adopter.
For those dogs whose history includes evidence of aggression, we may also require you to participate in and pay for an evaluation session at the Marin Humane Society or other expert testing situation or we may require you to participate in and pay for consultation and treatment at the Behavior Services of the UC Davis Veterinary Medicine Teaching Hospital in order to enable us to make a decision as to whether or not this dog is rehabilitatable for placement.
We realize that filling out this evaluation is difficult and time consuming, but we have had an unfortunate case in which a surrendering owner concealed the fact that the dog had bitten someone (seriously enough for an insurance settlement to have to be made). Although that dog seemed quite normal and friendly during foster care , after adoption the dog bit someone else. The former owner is now being sued. The dog of course was ultimately euthanized (killed).
We are willing to do rehabilitative work for dogs with many kinds of problems, if we have an appropriately skilled foster home and if we have hope that the problem can be rehabilitated or managed safely so the dog is adoptable.
In the event that we are unable to accept your dog into our program because the dog's existing problems make it an unacceptable risk to the foster home or the future adopter, we strongly urge you to take the dog to consultation and behavioral treatment at the Behavior Services of the UC Davis Veterinary Medicine Teaching Hospital or to a similarly qualified source of help, ie with a board certified Veterinarly Behaviorist or with a certified Applied Animal Behaviorist. Sometimes a dedicated and loving owner can rehabilitate the dog with this expert help. In any case , you will need professional advice as to how you should modify your training and management practices so as to avoid creating similar problems with another dog in the future.
I , the owner, agree to these terms and have answered all questions honestly :
Owners signature : __________________________________________________
date : _______________
Instructions for filling out form :
The "SITUATION" column describes an event that may or may not have ever happened to the dog while in your ownership.
Some of these situations occur very often in most normal homes, and some occur rarely or not at all.Human means any human including a child. Dogs person means any human in the dogs family. Child means anyone under age of 18. Stranger means anyone dog does not know well. Try to make note of what category of human is most often involved in any of the undesirable reactions; if it is a child try to note the age and sex of the child ; if adult, try to note the sex of the adult.
The "HOW OFTEN ?" column is to record whether the situation described in the "SITUATION" column has occurred N = never (0r at last never observed by you), 1 = once, R = rarely (ie a few instances, probably 3 or less) , or C = commonly ( = often).
The "DOG'S REACTION" sub-columns describes the dog's reaction to this event. For each and every reaction you have observed, please note N = never, 1 = once only, R = rarely (ie a few instances, less than a quarter of the times the situation has occurred), and C = commonly (more than a quarter of the times the situation has occurred), and A = always or almost always. Please notice that some of these reactions are desirable ones (indicating calm trusting acceptance), others indicate fearfulness, and some indicate a potential aggression or flagrant aggression problem. Any fear or aggression problem is one must be worked on with methods of desensitization and counter-conditioning to get the dog to the point where he reacts to that type of situation with calm trusting acceptance instead of fear or aggression. His life and the safety of his family depend on it !!!
SITUATION | HOW OFTEN ? how often situation seen ? |
DOGs REACTION (if situation has ever occurred & been seen) In each sub-column , put N = never, 1 = once, R = rarely, C = commonly ( = often) , or A = almost always |
|||||||||
situation = something to which dog may react |
N = never 1 = once R = rarely C = often = common |
No reaction (no identified reaction) |
Relaxes & accepts |
Enjoys situation or asks for more contact |
Cowers Lowers body and/or tucks tail |
With- flees or tries to flee |
Freezes |
Growls, snarls, or angry bark |
Lifts lip |
Snaps |
Bites |
Human casually walks past dog while dog is eating (meal or special food) |
|||||||||||
Human approaches while dog is eating (meal or special food) |
|||||||||||
Human tries to pick up dish while dog is eating (meal or special food) |
|||||||||||
Human tries to pick up people food that has fallen to floor while dog is trying to reach that food |
|||||||||||
Human tries to touch bone, rawhide, or other special food that dog is eating or holding in paws |
|||||||||||
Human tries to take away bone, rawhide, or other special food that dog is eating or holding in paws |
|||||||||||
Human tries to touch or take away a toy that dog is playing with |
|||||||||||
Human tries to touch or take away some item dog has stolen (eg shoe, kleenex, underwear, or whatever) |
|||||||||||
Human approaches while dog is playing with toy or stolen item |
|||||||||||
Human approaches or disturbs dog while it is sleeping |
|||||||||||
Human steps over dog . |
|||||||||||
Human pushes dog off of sofa, chair, or people bed |
|||||||||||
Human reaches hand towards dog |
|||||||||||
Human reaches over dogs head |
|||||||||||
Human tries to put on leash and/or collar |
|||||||||||
Human grabs at dogs collar or neck |
|||||||||||
Human pulls on dogs collar or neck |
|||||||||||
Human hugs dog around neck |
|||||||||||
Human pushes down on dogs shoulders |
|||||||||||
Human pushes down on dogs rump |
|||||||||||
Human tries to get dog to lie down by voice command |
|||||||||||
Human tries to get dog to lie down by physical pushing |
|||||||||||
Human tries to get dog to roll over on its back by physical manipulation |
|||||||||||
Human tries to groom dogs head , torso, or legs (ie other than feet) |
|||||||||||
Human touches dogs feet or uses comb or scissors on dogs feet |
|||||||||||
Human clips or tries to clip dogs toenails |
|||||||||||
Human tries to bathe dog, including toweling off after bath |
|||||||||||
Human holds dog by snout and tries to move head back and forth |
|||||||||||
Human tries to open dogs mouth or tried to put pills into mouth |
|||||||||||
Human handles dogs ears or tries to put medicine in ears |
|||||||||||
Human stares into dogs eyes |
|||||||||||
Human scolds dog in loud voice |
|||||||||||
Human yells loudly near dog |
|||||||||||
Human threatens dog with object such as newspaper or with hand |
|||||||||||
Human hits dog with object held in hand or with hand (accidentally or deliberately) |
|||||||||||
Human bumps dog with knee or foot (accidentally or deliberately) |
|||||||||||
Human trips over dog or drops object on or near dog |
|||||||||||
While dog is lying down human lies behind dogs back than slips leg over dogs rear and arm over dogs shoulders, then rest a bit of weight on both of these (children do this often !) |
|||||||||||
Human pulls on dogs ears gently or on dogs tail gently. (children do this and often not gently) |
|||||||||||
Baby crying or child shrieking |
|||||||||||
Dog approached by infant or toddler (child under 2 years) |
|||||||||||
Dog approached by child 2 to 4 years (familiar or strange child) |
|||||||||||
Dog approached by child 5 to 7 years (familiar or strange child) |
|||||||||||
Dog approached by child 8 to 11 |
|||||||||||
Dog approached by child 12 to 16 |
|||||||||||
Dog playing with child 2 to 4 |
|||||||||||
Dog playing with child 5 to 7 |
|||||||||||
Dog playing with child 12 to 16 |
|||||||||||
Dog playing tug of war with any human |
|||||||||||
Dog playing rough-housing or wrestling type of game with any human |
|||||||||||
Child sits on dog or attempts to do so (children should not be permitted to do this but they will do it anyway) |
|||||||||||
Human in wheelchair , or using walker or cane approaches dog |
|||||||||||
Human in wheelchair , or using walker or cane accidentally bumps into dog |
|||||||||||
Stranger knocks on door or rings bell at dog's home |
|||||||||||
Stranger enters house (guest, not burglar) |
|||||||||||
Stranger in house tries to pet dog |
|||||||||||
Stranger approaches dog in car at gas station |
|||||||||||
Dog in car at toll booth |
|||||||||||
Stranger approaches dog on street while walked by family member |
|||||||||||
Stranger approaches dog on street while dog tied to fixture, with family member out of sight or some feet distant but in sight |
|||||||||||
Skateboarder , bicyclist, or jogger passes dog while dog walked on street |
|||||||||||
Skateboarder , bicyclist, or jogger passes dog while dog free in fenced yard |
|||||||||||
Skateboarder , bicyclist, or jogger passes dog while dog near window inside house. |
|||||||||||
Ordinary pedestrians pass while dog free in yard |
|||||||||||
Another person touches or hugs dogs person in dogs presence (consensual touch, not an attack) |
|||||||||||
Another person speaks loudly to dogs person in dogs presence |
|||||||||||
Another person speaks angrily to dogs person in dogs presence |
|||||||||||
Another person strikes or attacks dogs person in dogs presence |
|||||||||||
A strange dog approaches dog calmly or makes play bow to dog |
|||||||||||
A strange dog approaches dog in an assertive or aggressive manner |
|||||||||||
Strange dog passes while dog free in fenced yard |
|||||||||||
Another dog puts its chin or its paws on/over dogs shoulders or back |
|||||||||||
Another dog mounts dogs rump |
|||||||||||
Another dog approaches while dog is eating (meal or special food) |
|||||||||||
Another dog approaches while dog is playing with toy or stolen item |
|||||||||||
Another dog approaches or disturbs dog while it is sleeping |
|||||||||||
Cat approaches dog calmly |
|||||||||||
Cat approaches dog aggressively |
|||||||||||
Cat runs in presence of dog |
|||||||||||
Squirrels , rabbits, etc running |
|||||||||||
During visits to veterinarian |
|||||||||||
During visits to groomer |
|||||||||||
During stays at a pet sitters home |
|||||||||||
During visits by a pet sitter to dogs home in owners absence |
|||||||||||
During visits to boarding kennel |
site author Pam Green | copyright 2003 |
created 12/7/04 | revised 7/20/05 |
return to top of page | return to Site Index |